📋 Checklist for Open Peer Review #

Before conducting an open peer review, use this checklist to ensure that you are following ICArEHB’s policy and best practices:

Constructive Feedback:

• Have I provided clear, respectful, and constructive feedback aimed at improving the manuscript?

• Have I offered specific suggestions for improving the study’s methodology, analysis, or conclusions?

Objectivity:

• Is my review based solely on the merits of the research, free from personal bias or external influence?

• Have I avoided personal attacks or subjective criticisms unrelated to the scientific content?

Transparency and Accountability:

• If participating in open peer review, am I prepared to have my comments and identity publicly disclosed?

• Have I ensured that my feedback is clear, well-justified, and can stand up to public scrutiny?

Conflicts of Interest:

• Have I disclosed any potential conflicts of interest that could affect my ability to provide an unbiased review?

• If necessary, have I declined to review due to a conflict of interest?

Timeliness:

• Can I complete the review within the timeframe provided by the journal?

• If delays are unavoidable, have I informed the editor promptly?

Recognition:

• Have I tracked my peer review activities on platforms such as Publons or ORCID for professional recognition?

• Have I ensured that my reviewing efforts are visible and acknowledged where appropriate?